The need to invest more in women-identifying and BIPOC documentary filmmakers by addressing inherent power imbalances in the film funding ecosystem is not new, as CMSI’s 2020 study, The State of the Documentary Field, has found. What is new is a growing awareness among grantmakers to shift to a trust-based approach to documentary film funding, an emerging movement in philanthropy that film, media and arts funders unpacked in a recent webinar, An Era of Power Reckoning: Trust-Based Philanthropy and the Implications for Documentary Film Funding.
Hosted by Color Congress and the Trust-Based Philanthropy Project, the discussion opened with moderators Sonya Childress and Shaady Salehi describing trust-based philanthropy as a growing movement among grantmakers to address racial injustice by replacing the top-down, compliance-oriented paradigm of traditional philanthropy with a culture based on transparency, relationship-building, and a redistribution of power for a more equitable, healthy nonprofit ecosystem.
CMSI executive director Caty Borum next summarized key findings from CMSI’s research of 45 U.S.-based documentary organizations and 620 U.S. documentary film professionals, which showed BIPOC and women-identifying documentary filmmakers “being the most economically vulnerable, yet doing the lion’s share of social change storytelling work,” Borum said. Several key takeaways from the study underscored this point, including:
- 41% percent of filmmakers of color compared to 27% of white filmmakers rely on philanthropic funding as their main source of revenue
- 55% percent of BIPOC filmmakers made no revenue compared to 35% of white filmmakers
- 72% percent of filmmakers of color addressed a social issue in their last documentary compared to 55% of white, 67% of women, and 49% of men filmmakers.
Opportunities Lost in Structural Barriers
Color Congress Co-Director, Sahar Driver, bolstered this data by sharing findings from her landscape scan of 200 philanthropic documentary film funding organizations. Commissioned by JustFilms of the Ford Foundation, Beyond Inclusion: The Critical Role of People of Color in the U.S. Documentary Ecosystem, examined how the documentary film ecosystem from 2016 to 2020 responded to structural barriers that left filmmakers of color and their community-centered stories under-funded and under-represented.
Recognizing that numerous white-led organizations serve filmmakers of color, Driver offered several helpful takeaways:
- Only a small number—90—of the 200 people of color-led organizations studied were uniquely positioned to sustain their organizations’ commitments to elevate POC-centered documentary filmmaking
- Only nine of these 90 organizations received philanthropic funding between 2016 to 2020
- 85% of organizations that played a role in distribution were led by leaders of color, yet these organizations were perpetually overlooked and under-resourced
- 40% percent of organizations brought in an annual revenue under $100,000
- An estimated 1-5% of philanthropic funding went to POC-led organizations developing stories by and about people of color, which means organizations aspiring to do more were forced to stay small.
A Culture of Access
With these findings in mind, panelists Molly Murphy from Working Films, Denae Peters from Perspective Fund, Eleanor Savage from the Jerome Foundation, and Sonya Childress from Color Congress discussed ways film funders can better understand BIPOC filmmakers, remove barriers to funding BIPOC-led film projects, and direct funding to filmmakers who are the most vulnerable. Highlighting the need to take a values-based approach to film funding, panelists shared best practices for creating a trust-based culture in philanthropy that intentionally centers on grantors increasing BIPOC filmmakers’ access to grant resources and actively building relationships with grantees. Examples of impactful best practices that panelists have implemented include:
- Eliminating unnecessary, labor-intensive reports and streamlining paperwork
- No longer requiring grantees to provide impact metrics
- Focusing on two-way, intentional conversations to understand a grantee’s motivation and connection to the film subject (for more, see Trust-Based Philanthropy’s tips for facilitating verbal reports)
- Providing online FAQs, translation, ASL and other digital services and tools that help grant applicants through the funding application process.
In closing, Childress emphasized that funders must shift away from offering restricted, project-specific funding and instead prioritize unrestricted grant support for BIPOC-led organizations. Her challenge captured the opportunity for funders to make a real and lasting difference in the documentary film ecosystem:
“We need historic investment to correct historic disinvestment. The greatest commitment we can offer to support the most vulnerable is to provide unrestricted funding.” — Sonya Childress
To learn more about creating a trust-based grant-making culture, check out these Trust-Based Philanthropy resources:
- Read an overview of Trust-Based Philanthropy
- Download The 6 Grantmaking Practices of Trust-Based Philanthropy resource guide
- Join the TBP Peer Exchange, a listserv for grantmakers to share questions and insights about the journey of trust-based philanthropy
If you missed the An Era of Power Reckoning webinar or want to share it with others, you can access the recording and download the presentation slides. You can also pull up a full transcript of the event.
Read more on trends in documentary filmmaking and funding in Caty Borum’s book, Story Movements: How Documentaries Empower People and Inspire Social Change (Oxford University Press), at https://www.indiebound.org/book/9780190943424.